So which theories survived Chapters 3+4?

there should be an in-between section called “Barely Alive Theories”

Theories on life support

The ketchup blood theory fills me with so much anger that I struggle to respond to it calmly anymore

It’s so popular in the fandom but it’s so bad

Okay, I’m going to try

Why would Toby do that

By that I mean why would Toby make Sans bleed on screen and not explain it if it’s just some meaningless shitpost or something

This is a fictional story, not real life, so things happen because the author wants you to get something from it, not just because they happen

Does he just want to make the fans confused so he can laugh at them

The scene seemed dead serious, and again, he never explains it so far

And why can you accept all the other mysterious unexplained things about Sans but not that he has blood

And it doesn’t really matter that the blood and ketchup are the same color since Toby uses the same colors from a palette for different things sometimes, and either way, it just doesn’t prove anything on its own

Also, monster food is absorbed, it doesn’t pass through your body, and that would be a lot of liquid ketchup, so he would basically have to have a ketchup packet vest under his clothes

Additionally, if your problem is that he’s a skeleton, then bones do contain bone marrow, which I’ve heard can bleed, so if he’s a Deltarune monster, it could be like that, I dunno

Lastly, if you’re going to assume Sans couldn’t have bled and that we can’t assume he did, then why can we assume Susie bled

Tricky Tony probably just meant for it to be the red church juice coursing through her veins, it means nothing!!!

This is further supported by Serious Mode being on during the entirety of the Sans fight

Skeletons are the most dryed version of a human

If you takes out all the water in your body, you turn into a Sansalike

So skeletons can’t bleed, but are the only monster to make sense to turn into dust

No, that would be a mummy

Okay then takes out the skin, any clothes and everything except bones

:sans:

Pyrope?

Pyrope don’t even is humanoid

Please can you guys put a little of logic into why a skeleton is bleeding

They don’t have fluids

Think about fossils

Minecraft and D&D skeletons

None of them have umidity

Sans shouldn’t bleed

Unless that wasn’t blood

But ketchup certainly isn’t fitting for the scene

too comic

maybe that jelly thing that has inside bones?

I’m glad you see the tone discrepancy

I do think it could have to do with the bone marrow (stuff inside bones) like I mentioned earlier

I’m a Sans is from Deltarune believer so I think either way the fact he has like red in his anatomy is because of the universe he’s from

Bone marrow…

Bone marrow is literally blood…

Not literally, but like I mentioned, it is the source of blood, so it’s not that crazy that blood would come out

Okay for 1 second i believed we were going into a concordance

But this is just too ridiculous to be a theory

First: if it was true, Toby would probably put some very little reference to this, like Sans almost revealing he is familiar with the people in that place

Second: If he comes from Deltarune and goed to Undertale, he would know that the “voice” on the other side of the Ruins’s door is Toriel

Third: its just absurd and doesn’t match with the games’s aspect in general

I wouldn’t say my theory is definitely true but I have evidence

Sans bleeds when no other monsters do, even when injured in the same way, except for Susie, who is from Deltarune

Sans wants to go back to somewhere other than the surface, probably requiring the broken machine, but can’t

The Place Where it Rained - It’s Raining Somewhere Else

Papyrus talks about green grass when asked about where they lived before Snowdin

Sans is associated with Gaster

I think, with Sans not recognizing Toriel, it’s unclear whether he does

I don’t expect he would ever say “y’know, i actually come from a parallel reality, so i kind of already was that lady’s friend before i met her”

I’ve heard somebody argue he wasn’t even sure who she was until he saw her face to face

About it being ridiculous and silly or something, I think we just differ in opinion there

If I’m right or wrong in a future chapter, I’ll definitely have more to say about it then

Please don’t use the music’s name as a justificative

And no one said Sans does has a direct relation with Gaster, do you remember how the Blasters were from Papyrus?

Yeah, ever since watching a video that gave all this stuff that supports the theory, I'm subcribed to UT Sans = DR Sans theory. IT JUST MAKES SENSE.

But it IS. THEY HAVE SIMILAR NAMES FOR A REASON.

No, no one DID say Sans has a direct relation to Gaster, it's just a widely-accepted headcanon. But something else that was never once stated was that the Gaster Blasters are from Papyrus. Sure, he said that if he'd gotten to use his special attack that you'd "BE BLASTED TO BITS", but that's not a DIRECT confirmation. His special attack could've been a bomb of some sort. They blast things too.

Then why Toby literally needed to interrupt the fight?

Everyone knows the Annoying Dog :dog: only interveins when there is no logical justificative for why something happened, like impeding you from going with Susie and Ralsei, stealing Papyrus’s Attack and absorbing the legendary artifact.

A simple Hydrogen Bomb wouldn't be able to kill you, but the strongest weapon in the Tobyverse so far yes

Is this argument plausible for you?

Look, the reason the Annoying Dog intervened is because Toby probably thought it'd be funny if a dog stole Papyrus's attack (which I agree, it's funny)

There's likely no significance to the thing at all. Not everything Toby does is part of some continual game of 4D chess.

Nooo what i'm saying is that when he interveins is because there isn’t a logical reason for something to happen

Like, normally you would be able to go with Susie and Ralsei in Cyber City, but as :dogdance: didn't find a good reason for this, he put those Annoying Connedogs here to prohibit you from going there.