It’s a close match with the blade we see when we fight the Knight. I specifically mean the Knight’s blade in the boss fight.
1 Like
It looks nothing like the knight’s blades too
1 Like
No, no. He's got a point!
"THE KNIGHT WHICH MAKES WITH BLACKENED KNIFE"
This prophecy panel is meant to parallel that hologram, is it not?
1 Like
That too. Note the prophecy refers to one single knight. And the knight fights the heroes strife by strife. Which C3 Knight did. First in C3, then a few times in Chapter 4
Now let’s compare that with the knife we see the Knight use on Tenna.
Looking back, Carol’s conversation with Noelle ended before we left the manor. Because she leaves the kitchen to tell us we’re welcome. So she easily could have followed us in the same way whoever closed the storage closet door to trap us inside at the start of Chapter 1 did.
Carol's conversation with Noelle barely even started. There's no way she could have delivered a scolding or something on just the time Kris took to walk to the door.
And the church only has one entrance. Even if she had left Noelle hanging, she couldn't have appeared in front of us.
Time’s a really loose thing in interactive video games. The fact of the matter is, Carol left the kitchen to talk to us. She couldn’t have seen us leaving from behind closed doors. So she must have finished. Otherwise we wouldn’t see her come out. If we can argue that the Knight just so happened to show up just in time to get rid of Tenna whether we rush through the puzzles or take long on purpose, we can also argue Carol took exactly as long as it took us to leave the house, whether we explore for a bit or just bolt right out. We don’t even know how long the talk with Noelle was, we know the one with Susie was very short. It could have just been. “You are to never hang out with Susie EVER again, she’s been a TERRIBLE influence. If she’s going to make you help her break the ONE RULE we have on THAT ONE ROOM, don’t hang out with her EVER.” You can fit that in two textboxes. Which can be read rather quickly. In fact, a more likely possible is just “Susie. Is. Trouble. Never. Let. Her In. This House. AGAIN.” That fits in one textbox, though each small segment might just get its own anyway. Point is, I don’t think it was a long talk. Because we literally see that it’s over. If it wasn’t over, Carol wouldn’t have left, now, would she have? And we see her leave the kitchen. So it’s over. This reminds me of the “Kris didn’t make a Dark Fountain, that was a gas leak, because only the Knight should make fountains” stuff from the Chapter 2 days. We saw what we saw. Let’s not pretend that something we literally saw happen didn’t happen.
She was behind us. Like whoever closed the door in Chapter 1. I propose it’s the same idea here. (We still don’t know who THAT person was.) Then, after we enter the second room, she did her Knight-bird thing from when she stole Undyne to fly to the top of the stairs. Our time doing the piano puzzle is the perfect time for her to do this, did you miss how fast the Knight was during that scene with Undyne? And the chase to the bunker?
Evidence against Carol knight.
Why would Carol go to the church?
She was with Noelle when we discovered the dark world, so why would she go to the (EMPTY) church, leaving Noelle?
If I was the knight, I wouldnt do that, especially if my daughter says that I went out last night right before they found the dark world. And she most likely would, considering that one of them is her childhood best friend, and the other her love interest.
Incorrect buzzer sound
No.
There's a part two from the scrapped Tenna quiz.
One Roaring Knight isn't to say there can't be an opening fountain Knight- the Strange Knight Seam mentions.
I’d even make the argument that the Mikes might parallel the Knights. (Though I haven't fought the Mikes yet, which could be a problem.)
If there are multiple Knights, the design on the Roaring Knight should have references to all three of the Knights.
The antlers on the helmet being Carol and Asgore, with the Roaring Knight being Papyrus.
Strange Knight being Asgore, he was literally hiding in the bushes during Chapter 4. Obviously he could've opened the Church Dark World.
The third Knight I have no title for, but they are Carol. Carol’s job is to plan stuff, the Mayor has a lot of knowledge on the town after all.
Carol calls Kris because she needs to keep Susie out of the Bunker.
Who has connection to the Police? Asgore.
Who has connection the Church? Papyrus, maybe.
Who has connection to tree’s? Carol, as Susie already says.
The three symbols are representative of the three Knights.
Also, just as Alphys says, Carol happens to take Undyne to the shelter, with Papyrus running back to his house.
I ABSOLUTELY REFUSE PAPYRUS KNIGHT MY BOY CAN NOT BE EVIL I DONT WANT HIM TO BE
Well, he fits the shape of the Knight we do see… And I have no better candidate for a Roaring Knight…
About the Sans is Sans theory: Sans is a skeleton, so that is not blood, that is ketchup.
Just see Susie’s page(ALERT: i don’t remember well, i could be wrong), it says something about she being the first monster to visibly bleed
AaAaAaAh, did my vision suddenly decrease? Everything’s blurry!
1 Like
I know a good theory that can refute that f#cking thing about the "Papyrus Knight" theory:
My own theory is that the Knight is a Harbinger(noted my nametag?) of the Roaring. He don’t has a backstory, nor he is a already known character... I think he is here just to fulfill the prophecy, creating the fountains to wake the Titans. If this was true, that would explain why we don’t see lasers being fired off-screen by the Titan(trying to hit the Knight), a supposedly "mindless" being, only existing to destroy. They would be on the same side, and thus wouldn’t attack each other...
Also, i have a theory that the Titans, the Roaring Knight and the Roaring itself are the last-ditch effort of the world to stop something worst, like, maybe a good plot twist is that, in the supposed final battle, i think against the Angel(?) could reveal that, by defeating those beings and stopping the Roaring, we could be freeding something worst. I imagine the Voice being this.
Ok but body shape is why I chose Papyrus
Jockington holds potential to be the Roaring Knight
It is still likely that the Roaring Knight is an Amalgamate, but Papyrus would be the one way to avoid Amalgam and make it more Mike esque (Haven't fought them, so I might be making them less Mike esque)
NGAHHH!! THAT PAPYRUS KNIGHT “THEORY” IS ONLY A JOKE SOMEONE BELIEVED AS REAL IT DOESN’T MAKES SENSE!!!!!!!!
I just told you the reason I chose Papyrus and who else could work from my reasoning…
ALWAYS BET ON PAPYRUS KNIGHT
Ok, bit of a stretch…
But Kris Knight is still plausible if the Knight is some sort of Kris from the future (Light-year Zurg and Buzz kinda thing)