I have a theory and a question

so, everyone talks about "who is the roaring knight?", "who is the roaring knight?", "who is the roaring knight?", but i have a better question:

what if the roaring knight

is just a new character?

like, idk why we are overcomplicating this

its prob just a lightner driven insane by the dark

...

personally, idk about this theory.

@HarbingerKnightTheSecond your personal theory has something to do with this, right?

TO: finally someone KNOWS

my theory is that they were created solely with the purpose of fullfilling the Prophecy, hence the name
who created them? certainly Gaster bullshit

Personally, I think Gaster 's a good guy. He's trying to give the characters freedom, and the Knight brigade is trying to take that away

i've been considering this for a while and i'm glad somebody else said it.

Yeah

(You closed your eyes.)
(The image of the Knight began to fade into your mind.)
(The image changes... the helmet begins to come off.)
(Suddenly, you tried extremely hard to picture Jockington.)
(Jockington is in a nest, and the soccer balls are his eggs.)
(Temmie shows up, and is mad that one of the soccer balls is...)
(...)
(You realized you could just open your eyes.)

This is Kris actively hiding the Knight's identity from us.

where the freak does this happen

If you refuse to "close your eyes and think of Susie" in Chapter 4, Ralsei suggests thinking of someone else.

What Remix said, there's a choice to think of the Knight