The Thrash Machine will not show up in future chapters

If it did show up, it would almost certainly create a continuity error.

If you create a Chapter 3 SAVE without a Chapter 2 Completion File, Tenna still shows the quiz question about the Thrash Machine, but with a randomly generated machine. To make it fair, the swapped piece is a complete fake that the Thrash Machine cannot be built with:

The implication is that this (minus the fake piece) is the machine that was actually built in the unplayed chapter. If the Thrash Machine appears in future chapters, it should match this randomly generated design.

However, the game never saves this design! If the machine does appears again later, it will have different parts (unless they match by complete luck). A SAVE file that starts in Chapter 3 and encounters the Thrash Machine in a future chapter will almost certainly have a continuity error. This betrays Toby's intention of never having it appear again.

It should be noted that the game does generate and save a random Thrash Machine behind the scenes if you start the game after Chapter 1, but this machine goes unused if you start the game after Chapter 2. This is likely caused by the developers copying and pasting the game-start logic across chapters.

Yeah you are right because the more you progress the game, the more it gets serious. Chapter 4 is already very serious with a few jokes here and there. Chapter 3 is basically the same but a bit less serious and 1-2 aren't as so (unless your doing something like snowgrave or sword route)

so yeah solid theory

Please no one say it.

Say what

The thing.
Do not say it.

WHEN YOU CANT EVEN SAY
MY NAME

NOOOOOOO
WHAT HAVE I DONE

IS THE MEMORY GONE? ARE YOU FEELING NUMB!

YES I AM NUMB I AM NUMB BECAUSE OF THESE CONSTANT METAL GEAR REFERENCES
AND I STARTED THEM! I WAS THE ONE WHO STARTED IT!


Galacta about to SMASH the references

But really —
I think the Thrash Machine might show up later, perchance in the credit scenes, even if it doesn't show up main-game.
Why?
Because Toby doesn't tend to make some halfway thing and cut it, you can see in Hometown that a lot of minor NPCs are still there from UNDERTALE, meaning he doesn't stop using characters that easily.
That being said, I mostly just hopium the Thrash Machine gets used because I like it.

GIGA Queen may still show up though. (Please Toby :folded_hands:)

But if it does show up, credits or not, it won't be the correct machine for people who started playing in Chapter 3. If Toby wanted to make it appear later, he would have saved it.

Code is editable you know

Toby might have just accidentally forgotten to save this one

/j

I have a leaked internal document from Tony himself that says that the thrash machine is being replaced by Gandalf the Grey and Gandalf the White and Monty Python and the Holy Grail's Black Knight and Benito Mussolin, and the Blue Meanie, Cowboy Curtis and Jambie the Genie, Robocop, The Terminator, Captain Kirk, Darth Vader, Lo Pan, Superman, every single Power Ranger, Bill S. Preston and Theodore Logan, Spock, The Rock, Doc Ock and Hulk Hogan

tbf, jevil didn't give you a shadow crystal back in 2018 either

I do think Toby is making a slight pivot from the jokes. They still clearly exist and are going to exist, considering the entirety of the Jackenstein fight is one big meme, but I do think they're getting intentionally phased out to focus more on story beats.

what are these games??

The ones I've played before

It wouldn't help any existing Chapter 3 SAVEs. Those machines are gone for good.

I doubt it's a mistake. Remember when I said that the game generates a random Thrash Machine behind the scenes if you start the game after Chapter 1? The quiz could have just read the appropriate flags, and it would have a machine that was already saved. This is what the Rouxls fight in Chapter 2 does. But the quiz completely ignores the perfectly good machine in the SAVE file and creates a new one from scratch.

This change in approach between chapters suggests a change in intention. If the team wanted to use the machine in the future, they would have done the same thing they did in Chapter 2.

But Toby included dialogue retroactively explaining that Kris was unknowingly carrying the Shadow Crystal all this time. Without knowledge of the correct parts, the game literally cannot depict the Thrash Machine.