The 10th Anniversary Stream's canonicity

So, with stuff like the new locations and music, Gerson's big lore dump about the war and Chara apparently being the "someone else" saved in the battle with Asriel, do we add such information to the respective pages or do we just keep it on the stream's page? Toby's comments throughout the event heavily imply that everything shown is in a weird gray area of "it's as canon as you want it to be", so I find it best to try and settle this matter right now to prevent cases like people rushing to add it and then finding their changes reverted.

I’m in favour of a compromise until we receive a possibility-excluding answer from Toby (which I think, considering his choice of words, is very unlikely to happen): Event-only dialogue should be added, but with a disclaimer that it’s exclusive to the special edition written for the 10th Anniversary, so players won’t get confused over these changes not being accessible in the regular game.

Example format I used: Gerson (Dialogue, Trivia)
Example disclaimer text: “This content is exclusive to a special version written for the UNDERTALE 10th Anniversary stream. It may not be accessible in the official UNDERTALE game and possibly not be considered a canonical part of the story.”

I say we don't edit anything until we get confirmation of anything from Toby.

And if we get nothing in the next couple months, we make a page dedicated to the livestream content.

Toby has already stated that nothing outside of the games are canon, and has stated that the extra content on stream is just his own answers to "what if" questions. I think it should stay on the stream page, and maybe be included in the respective pages' trivia if the content is particularly noteworthy.

Fair enough, if he ever explicitely said that during another point. I wasn’t aware of such a comment, if it exists, sorry.

In this case, I see no reason to wait several months in hope for further confirmation before adding it to the stream-dedicated page. Almost everything published on the UT/DT site is also featured on the Wiki, despite not being confirmed canon.
If no one else objects to your idea to split it between the stream page and particularly noteworthy content into Trivia, I'd like to re-submit my edits on each with the respective changes (additional dialogue to the stream page, a summary of Gerson's comment on Human-Monster relations to his Trivia). (Edit: It has partially already been added back.)

I wrote down Toby’s full comment during the stream (up to the part where he mentions what will be released) which starts around 4:50:25, it could provide helpful context to have a better picture of his opinion:

Bark
  • but yeah about all the extra stuff on the stream
  • pretty much everything was smoke and mirrors and we show you everything you can do with it
  • so if you had it it would probably break instantly so it's not very practical to share
  • the second reason is because I don't want it to actually be in the game, I like the game as it is now
  • about the new areas, it's basically just a ´what if´
  • but this ´what if´ was always there
  • it never wasn't there and it will never not be there
  • every monster has a place to go home to
  • Every monster has to have friends, they have to something to eat, somewhere to go hang out
  • the underground is a wide place
  • the only limit to all of this your imagination
  • My goal with these days wasn't to show you a new hidden truth you will never be able to access
  • My goal was to remind you that you have always been able to go if you just hold the key of asking "What's there?"
  • What's under the bridge? What's beyond the horizon?
  • Maybe you guys feel only my answer to these questions counts or matters
  • But to me I only feel the opposite
  • This is just one interpretation
  • the underground is as big as you want it to be
  • and I invite you to come behind the wall with me

...and just because it's too valuable on an emotional level to be forgotten.

"Bark"
So inspiring

I added a link to this "Bark" under a different title to the livestream page. The additions will likely make readers that weren't there wonder if they should be considered canon or not - it is technically part of the game, just not in the official release. Toby's statement on the matter could help avoiding edit wars by promoting a neutral POV and clarify why he doesn't want to add them to the main game.

Dude's more than busy with Deltarune and other projects for the extra workload that would be involved with maintaining this build for now.

Like with every post-release content, it’s in some weird gray area. I’m pretty sure this is how Toby wants it to be, but considering the state of the fourth wall (non-existent), I'm fairly certain all new content is canon to it's own iteration like how a multiverse works.

(Yes, I apply quantum theory to my fanon, how could you tell?)

Ultimately, I consider the in-game content on day one unaltered to be fully canon, and any updated or added content from later updates, live streams and merchandise to be canon in it’s instance and according to personal preference. To use an example: the rose in the weird is the original so it’s ‘canon’ but the dot can still be considered ‘canon’ based on one’s first experience being with the dot. (Distinction without a difference; it works perfectly for an example.) Of course, all bets are off with fanon which is definitively non-canon in context and the fourth wall has already been smashed like the mercy button, repeatedly, so none of this really matters much.

Thanks for posting this here, I will try my best to brush up the additions section to have a little more context to it to reflect it!

I’d say it’s sorta-semi-kinda-maybe-perhaps-canon