I think we should create a separate page for the Thank You/”how long did it take her to smile” puzzle. It’s likely that the information it gives us will be very important for Chapter 5 and the Weird Route, and I think it should have its own page that explains who could participate, how people participated, the different responses to our answers, and (once the puzzle is solved) the meaning of those responses. It would also help reduce the length of the extremely long Spamton Sweepstakes page. What do you guys think of this?
I like the idea of having a dedicated page for every ARG-like thing that Toby does, but I think that if we had one for the "Thank You" one, it would be a stub because we don't have enough information.
Maybe not right now, but it’s not over yet (the response emails he sent out said “until next time” as the caption). Round 2 also gave us way more information than round 1 did, so the next rounds could give us even more. We have other pages for stuff we don’t have much info on yet, but we know we’ll eventually get more info on (Chapters 5-7, festival, pre CH 3-4 we had Tenna, etc)
If only anyone put 1997
But yeah we did get "If you have a bat, everything looks like a ball" from 1225.
I think at this point its clear that its referring to Noelle. 1997 would probably just give “what are you getting at?” or something similar to "If you have a bat, everything looks like a ball", but Spamton.
On a side note, what ARG-like things are you talking about? I think that’s a great idea in order to reduce the length of the Spamton Sweepstakes page
Spamton Sweepstakes and Thank You, that's it for now
I kinda expect more in the future
We could do it kinda like the weird route page, with one main page where all puzzles are listed and summarized, and links to pages with more detailed descriptions of each puzzle. For Spamton Sweepstakes, do you mean we would split off the link maze into its own separate page? Or just put the whole page under the real life puzzles category?
Idk what way we should do it if we do, I'm just putting in my two cents
I hoped a new Sweepstakes-like event would happen in Dec 25 bc... y'know. 25/12/(20)25 12(20)25 1225
Nope, js a continuation of a preexisting one... sad
and it wasnt even on 25/12/25
@KockaAdmiralac what do you think about this
Again, it’s not an ARG, but it is something for Toby to interact with the fans.
I get you wanted to move the /thankyou/ information out of the Spamton Sweepstakes article, but this did need to be discussed more. Because it’s not just moving that one subheader, it’s everything else as well because the article is so packed with information.
I’ve already suggested this: it’s likely that we might need to have them split as sub articles for Spamton Sweepstakes. Spamton Sweepstakes/Noelle’s blog as an example.
In terms of /thankyou/, Xanderjedi11 brings up a good point about it. Plus, we don’t really if know if they will keep reusing this exclusive email listing. Right now, it’s only meant for people who are subscribed to the Newsletter and had replied to the 1st round. Some people even missed out on round 2, and we don’t know if they’ll be part of it again!
Again, it’s not an ARG, but it is something for Toby to interact with the fans.
I changed it to "Thank You Puzzle". Its more of a placeholder for now. If you have a better idea, please do change it.
I get you wanted to move the /thankyou/ information out of the Spamton Sweepstakes article, but this did need to be discussed more.
I agree. Discussion here had stopped, and I didn't want it to take months to resolve like some other topics did, so I figured just creating the page might restart discussion. And it did.
Because it’s not just moving that one subheader, it’s everything else as well because the article is so packed with information. I’ve already suggested this: it’s likely that we might need to have them split as sub articles for Spamton Sweepstakes. Spamton Sweepstakes/Noelle’s blog as an example.
I know the "Thank You" puzzle was technically accessed through the Sweepstakes links, but it feels way less connected to the Sweepstakes than the original links from 2022. For one, it is hinting at something in Chapter 5 or beyond, rather than 3/4, and all the information we get from it comes through email, not the website. I think it's separate enough to have its own article (it could of course still be linked to on the Sweepstakes page). As for your other point, great idea. Or we could split the page into 2: One for the actual event, and one for the link maze.
In terms of /thankyou/, Xanderjedi11 brings up a good point about it. Plus, we don’t really if know if they will keep reusing this exclusive email listing. Right now, it’s only meant for people who are subscribed to the Newsletter and had replied to the 1st round. Some people even missed out on round 2, and we don’t know if they’ll be part of it again!
Anyone who missed 1, didn't get to participate in 2, so I think its likely that people who missed 1/2 won't get to participate in 3. I guess they could switch to something that isn't the email listing, but why does that mean we can't write down the part we have right now? We've had and have a lot of articles over things we have incomplete information about (Tenna pre Ch3-4, future Chapters, festival, etc). It will probably end up being very important. Having its own page will help us beat Fandom by pulling people who search for it to this wiki, and, at the very least, its better than having the info about it buried 3/4 of the way into the longest article on the wiki.
I think it would be better that you and others try to bring it up to other wiki moderators and admins next time than suddenly make a new article. We’re trying to sort out the info in the wiki in general, which is a lot.
The 2022 links can be split from the silence links. I don’t think /thankyou/ needs a split from the silence links because they’re hinting at Weird Route and other secrets anyways. Not only that but the “Allusions to Deltarune” section can be merged into them.
Again, the main issue is that we don’t know if Fangamer/Toby will reuse the email listing for a third round, if there even is a 3rd. That’s the main issue about /thankyou/ being separate next to it being a stub.
Ok, I get your arguments for not having a separate thank you page. We can always make one later depending on how much new information we get and how important it is.
Just to make sure I understood you correctly:
-Split off 2 sub articles (1 for 2022 links, 1 for silence links)
-merge thank you and allusions to Deltarune into silence links
That sounds good to me.
Do you think making a poll or asking Kocka to make a poll would get more people to engage with this? Or should I just ask the admins directly?
Yes, everything is correct. Because /thankyou/ hints at some of Chapter 5, it would be strange to split it from /chapter5/ anyways.
“Allusions to Deltarune” can be merged into both “Link maze” and “Silence links” subarticles based on the information. Oh, and related Trivia as well! I think that’s the best way to go about it.
As for approaching, as you probably saw, I’ve pinged Kocka in the Discord to ask if it’s okay if we have polling possibly done for it on a separate thread.. Maybe someone else might have different ideas than me too!
Which is sad, because I subscribed to the newsletter for the FULL PACKAGE but because I didn't answer the OG I didn't get an email this last round
Yes I subbed before round 2 Thank You if my memory isn't faulty
I thought this was unfortunate too, but I guess they did that because round 1 submissions ended early, and they probably didn’t want to be overloaded with answers..