My five biggest theories for chapter 3

  • Mike is the main villain, not Tenna
  • Toby’s pulling a fast one with the end of Chapter 2
  • Bheaurghleighyh isn’t ded
  • Ralsei is villain!?!!!???!??!!??!?!?!!!? :0
  • A bunch of theories get proven wrong

My theory is
That
The Fun Gang
Are
The main characters

Ralsei: You’re acting pretty Rude, Buster!
Susie: Say that again…
Kris:

Nah there's no way Ralsei's evil
He may not be telling the entire truth, but he is NOT evil.
Also wasn't there a concept art of chapter 3 with a giant T

oh he's def hiding smth in ch 4

You’ll see

Also this aged horribly

the last 2 aged fine

maybe not evil Ralsei but sus ralsei

and yeah Toby screwed the theorists

Three and five are mostly correct, I wouldn't say Ralsei being evil was really correct at all

Ralsei is def sus
Haven't finished ch 4 but seems he's hiding something re: the prophecy

1 was so wrong…

What did the “fast one” thing mean

Did you believe in some slop like gas leak theory or

Yeah pretty much

I was thinking it was a 50/50 chance

Tenna was, in fact, the main villain
Toby wasn't pulling a fast one
Bhuereruhtugghrughewuhuoergpdskbopdtnndf wasn't dead
Ralsei isn't evil but was hiding things
And do I even need to say the last one?

True, although I think he’s fallen down or at least permanently incapacitated

Snowgrave is fatal so he’s definitely dead in the dark world

He’s just not dead in the light world yet

I’m surprised you still thought he was evil as you were playing through Chapter 3, most people got over that years before

I suppose that depends on how you look at it

I mean we certainly could have been wrong in MORE ways than we were

We predicted both the dark world locations, and there are lots of different details people predicted

There are also a lot of details that were wrong, especially with more fanfic-y theories

I will say that Dess knight was pretty fringe before Chapter 3 so a lot of knight theorists were definitely wrong

Yeah, I flipped between loving the fluffy goat boy and wanting him to suffer before 3&4 came out, but I will forever love him after the scene in the second sanctuary

I mean, if he’s not dead in the light world and recovers, then he won’t be dead in the dark world.

That’s why he’s not going to recover