All lightners have blood

Wiki is seemingly uncertain on question of DR Monsters having blood. Susie bleeding in chapter 4 obviously proves that she have it, but some think that it just proves that she is half-human. But we can see another example of monster bleeding. It being Noelle and infamous Weird Route scene, which obviously implied that we caused Noelle bleeding by putting ThornRing (probably just thorn in LW) on her finger.

Wiki doesn't have to declare officially that all lightners have blood. But it should add that Noelle is seemingly have blood too

The thing is that it’s just speculation to say this is blood. The rose or cracking effects seem pretty abstract, and a lot of people think the red dot afterwards might be something like a soul piece. Saying it’s blood does feel like the most simple explanation, but I don’t really see the need to include it on the wiki, in my personal opinion.

Susie says in Chapter 1 “Everyone bleeds, right?” and Lancer does not try to correct her, neither does Ralsei.

That would be fair to include a note about

Well it's evidence that “everybody bleeds”, right?

I misread what you put, I thought you said it would be too wordy or something

Honestly, what if we’re just all wrong, and monsters have always had blood.
Because sans bled.
Like they can bleed, and then turn into dust when they die.

Those things can both be true.

But in Undertale we literally watch them die, they never bleed. They only turn into dust.

Undertale, however, is a much simpler game. Toby probably only wanted to include blood in the part where it was most significant, that being sans’ death sequence

Sure they turn to dust. That happens. It might just not include the blood in undertale in favor of simply adding a disintegration graphic to the hurtsprite

I think that UT monsters don't bleed, DR monsters do (but not Darkners) which means SAND DELTARUNE = SAND UNDERTABLE

There is an NPC in DELTARUNE who can only be seen in a window. They ask Kris if it hurts being made of blood. I think this disproves this theory, much to my dismay.

I mean, we could hypothetically just never break skin.
They COULD just have strong skin

What so Toriel’s death isn’t significant enough
She has a giant cut

I basically agree with this genuinely except that I think the way darkners get hurt really just depends on what kind of darkner they are

Tenna shoots out sparks after getting limbs chopped off, Lancer talks about blood

If they just have strong skin, you wouldn't see the blood so it won't even matter.

I don't think they “just have strong skin”, as we clearly cut right through Undyne’s armor on Genocide before she goes Undying.

Sans pretty clearly bleeds.

If Toby wanted every monster to bleed he would've at least made the boss monsters bleed.

He only chose to make Sans bleed.

Monster blood and human blood are likely different types of blood, but I’m not sure if that changes this dialogue.

If the monster meant “does it hurt to be made of this blood type” they probably would've said that…

I agree with you on all of this

I think the “made of blood” line was either a writing mistake or it was supposed to be interpreted like “humans are made of blood (made of biological matter) and monsters are made of magic but have blood”

Toriel has dark red eyes, and yet Toby chose to not give her red blood when she was cut.

Despite the amount of times we see monsters slashed/cut, we never see blood (except for Sans).

Yeah

and Susie

I believe Sans comes from Deltarune