Maybe I'm forgetting some bit of dialogue, but what about Noelle’s feelings is “confirmed” that doesn’t apply to Susie? Personally, I’d say it’s pretty obvious that Noelle and Susie are developing a romance, but all I’m saying here is that I think the wiki should be consistent on what’s fact.
Susie hangs out with Noelle intimately, she takes Noelle on a date to the festival, which is treated as a romantic thing to do, such as in the way Susie talks about the festival with Rudy, and she gets very excited when the prophecy mentions love
I don’t remember either character saying outright how they see each other
And the whole scene with the guitar at Noelle's house too
it was there at some point, not sure why it got removed. i'm in favor of readding it, just wanna see if there was a reason for removal first
Is this on the topic of the infobox? I had removed it from both Susie and Noelle because I thought it would be better to expand more about about them having a crush with each other in the relationships subheader. I still have mixed feelings with the relationships for main characters in the infobox since their relationships subheaders are actually bigger than that… but it’d become bloated again.
An anon had readded it back to Noelle a while back, and I’m fine with readding it back to Susie.
This was prompted moreso by the character relationships section for Susie, where it says that she is only shown to view Noelle as a close friend
Thank you for your opinion on this matter
I think that we get pushback on this every time we do it. There’s a whole side of the fandom that really wishes Suselle doesn’t become canon, and in order to remain as neutral as possible we leave out the information about Susie potentially having a crush. In truth, Noelle’s side of the relationship has way more evidence to it (starting from Chapter 1, even), and Susie’s side is still not 100% confirmed, so anything we add would be speculation (based in facts, but still speculation). I’m not against it, I just wouldn’t be surprised to see people argue against that inclusion, or even that Kris should receive the same treatment as Susie (“Noelle (implied love interest)”).
I think that’s why I felt it was necessary to do my most recent change, as while it not only raises the possibility of Susie reciprocating those feelings, but it does so in a way that affirms that it is unconfirmed therefore should be treated as such. And I feel like this benefits both sides of the debate.
THERE IS?????
I’ve made some edits about this now, as well as adding to the relationships section in general a bit. I flip-flopped on phrasing a bit, but I hope that the current version should be agreeable to most people. It’s unfortunate that the description in the infobox of Susie’s relationship to Noelle ends up taking up two lines, but I don’t know how to phrase it in a shorter way that doesn’t sound biased towards one idea.
Unfortunately, yes. I think it’s mostly shippers who’ve been in the fandom for a while and prefer other pairings for the characters.
That's... kind of dumb, honestly, in my opinion
Shipping has never really appealed to me, but it’s a very passionate subculture, which is how things like this happen
It's kind of a dumb concept though- normally I'm fine with ships, but when it's directly contradicting the canon, it just feels stupid to me
Chapter 5 drama ![]()
Didn't you argue for a TLoZ ship that directly goes against canon and acknowledge the fact yourself?
Okay yeah good point, sorry...