My preference is to give at least one citation for every claim that isn’t common knowledge (e.g., when many casual fans might not know or be sure about it, in areas where fanon tends to be mistaken for canon), so I’m actually likely to follow this rule a little too well, at least in comparison with most contributors… Are there any guidelines for when citation can be too much?
That kind of citing for aliases reminds me of what the zeldawiki.wiki does, though they do that for the character’s infobox. I think if the citation itself makes it obvious who it is being referred to, it should be fine. So I’d think the first citation should be good for the “mailman” name.
I made a lot of changes to the personality section of Tenna. In only 20 hours there were nine edits added to it - damn, you guys are fast.
Seems like the acceptable number of citations is two for a single point.
Still waiting if they’ll cut down my citations further. I mean, look at that page. With the addition of hyperlinks to other pages, it looks like Papyrus did an old-version blue attack.
Anyway, my desire for extra citations was partly motivated by trying to cram as much details and obviously-canon analyses. Really wanted a wiki where we can document things like that, like “all the instances where a pronoun is used to refer to Kris” or “all dialogue where Spamton and Tenna [[$%!#]] on each other”. I know there are hundreds of individual posts on those but it’d be nice to have everyone’s contributions curated in one place. I might see if I can do a bit of that in the Deltarune Theories wiki, but that’s limited to theories.
Eh, another reason why I love excessive citations -
Sometimes I read someone citing a couple of instances of something happening and then saying it's evidence that that situation happens. Like, to talk about fandom - a character wears a rose on their hair for a day and then everyone thinks it's their favorite flower. Then fanon explodes - fanart full of roses, headcanons that it's their favorite flower, they have a rose garden. People start to forget or don't realize that character only wore a rose for a few hours.
So adding five citations feels like an indication that it's not the case here, the person really is like that.
Of course, when in Rome, do what the Romans do. Ad too many citations here does give a blue-attack effect, so I'll stick to the rules and norms here.