Shrine Guardian Seth vs. Violet Tactician Seth

We all know Seth, the viole(n)t tactician from Chapter 5 that frequently opposes the party along with Aqua. However, we also know Seth, the guardian of Nyleth's shrine in Silksong.

You may rest here in this sacred place, but know, if you choose to step further, you shall see my weapon raised.

Aqua!! Help me!! Come back!! Please!!

But which one would win in a fight?
There are a lot of differences despite their names.

  • Seth has a sword and shield. This means unlike Seth, this means he actually has something to melee with.
  • Seth doesn't fight unless his opponent actually wants to.
  • Seth has killed many foes whether unwillingly or willingly.
  • If Seth were to be no-diffed by Seth, he would consequently lose his memory.
  • Seth is a bug.
  • Seth is a flower turned human (sorta).
  • Seth can only melee with a book. How embarassing.
  • Seth uses Aqua as an ally. Without her, Seth is practically helpless (excluding Omega attacks).
  • Seth can retreat at will. This is because if Seth were to leave the battle, Seth wouldn't still be aggressive unless the battle is reinitiated.
  • Seth does not have a shield.

The fight could end in many different ways such as:

  • Seth winning (Seth resigns)
  • Seth turns Seth into a delicious flower salad
  • Seth beats Seth so hard he loses his memory for some reason
  • Seth allows Seth to pass by him

All this because 2 characters have the same name btw. Also, the he/him pronouns refer to Seth from Silksong. So pls dont kill.

Seth the shrine guardian is a descendant of a cancer patient.
Therefore Seth (SS) cannot possibly lose.

Hornet did kinda beat his ahh tho
he did survive and actually become passive lel

flower salad time

No.
THE POWER OF CANCER PATIENTS COMPELLS YOU...!


...Also, nail & shell.
You know how good HK/SS shells are.

You are filled with the power of cancer patients and Seth being sliced and diced into a flower salad.

SS Seth is a bug.
Seth is the size of a human.
I rest my case.

To give all contestants a fair chance, all contestants are sized equally

Seth is FUCKED

WHICH SETH

The one named Seth

Which one

Seth Deltarune or Seth Silksong

yknow, the one from the indie game.

Which indie game

The one that has a character named Seth

Game name?

it has L in the title

Say the name PLEASEEE

the name please

I'm just following along for the funnies