Questionable healing item logic in Deltarune

Ralsei explicitly states that the Dark World is an illusion and that healing items won't actually make you full in the Light World if consumed in the Light World.

By that logic, if Susie eats Light Candy, would an entire chalk box be consumed, and STILL somehow no hunger is replenished???

Literal ancient chocolate that Kris eats isn't even restoring in the LW???
Eating a LITERAL PART OF A CD doesn't cause damage in the LW???

What is this logic???

It disappears

:sparkles:

Wack gaster magicks

Unless I'm forgetting something, there are 2 times this is mentioned in the game:

* Man, I'm STILL hungry.
* It's like nothing I eat here matters.
* Shoulda stolen more money for the bake sale, I guess.
— Susie, Chapter 1

* The cakes I bake, the cotton candy we eat, it might be yummy.
* ... But, when you return to the Light World, you won't be full.
— Ralsei, Chapter 3

As I see it, neither dialogue implies that Dark World food can't be equivalent to Light World food, but rather they imply that none of it provides nutritional value. I think the few exceptions we know of have rational explanations:

  • Revive {Mint,Dust}/Peppermint crunch - gives you so much sugar that it brings you back from the dead
  • Tension {Bit,Gem,Max}/Orange hard candy - almost no nutritional value but the sour taste tenses you up
  • Light Candy/Chalk - sure, it gives you minerals, but it also has 0 calories
  • Ancient Sweet/Ancient Chocolate - dried up and inedible unless you're Kris who's freaky about chocolate (for whom it recovers a fuckton of HP)

As for CD Bagels, I don't know. Surely, they don't just eat them.

The logic doesn't make sense tho. WHY TF DOES IT GIVE 0 CALORIES

Chalk is a type of rock and contains no carbohydrates, no proteins, and no fats (or any organic compounds for that matter).

Pretty sure CD Bagels are CD chunks or something (source: that one pockets convo in the church)

I know. What I'm saying is there's no way they end up in characters' stomachs. Susie could definitely pull it off, but Kris not so much. Maybe they just lick them or something.

Seems flimsy

(Yes I have argued against this but this isn’t too egregious)

See Pixel it can be funny sometimes

Not when you accuse people of “gooning” though

I never did that

Not you, but somebody else did

But yeah not cool beans

Very very hot beans in fact

:chara:

:friend: :-1:

Did Pixel NOT tell you to not take quotes out of context like that?

deltarune-gun

2 Likes

aargh i so badly want to save that gif

Do it